Skip to main content





Kids Join Music to Play — So Let Them

Increase playing time by keeping all students engaged, giving concise explanations and providing practice time for percussionists.

I once heard a story about a well-known college band director being asked about best rehearsal techniques. His response was simple: “They got horns? Play ’em.”

Students join band because they want to play an instrument. Choir students want to sing. Yes, they also join because their friends are there and because music gives them a place to belong. But ultimately, they just want to play.

Sometimes students get to rehearsal, put together their instrument, sit down … and spend a lot of time not playing.

As the director, I’m guilty of creating this situation. I’ve given explanations that were longer than the passage we were rehearsing. I’ve stopped 80 students from playing so I could work with eight. I’ve spent rehearsal time passing out papers that could have been handed out earlier.

Some of this is unavoidable because rehearsal requires instruction, listening, correction and occasionally dealing with behavior. More playing is not a cure for every classroom problem.

But it’s made me ask myself: “When students aren’t playing, why not?” And if there isn’t a good answer to this question, I get them playing.

student hands connected in a circle

Keep Everyone Involved

One of the easiest places to lose students is when we work with another section. The clarinets need help at measure 47, so everyone else sits there while we rehearse it six times. Sometimes that’s necessary. The rest of the ensemble needs to hear the clarinet part or understand how their music fits around it.

I can increase engagement, if I find something musical for everyone else to do. Depending on the passage, students can:

  • Hiss their parts while fingering.
  • Finger silently along with another section.
  • Sing or count their rhythm.
  • “Bop” their part with short articulations.
  • Play along quietly when appropriate.
  • Listen for one specific musical item they can report out on.

I also try to rehearse enough music to make the repetition worthwhile. Eight measures gives students more context than repeatedly attacking one note. Of course, sometimes one note really is the problem. In that case, I tell them exactly what we’re doing.

“We’re playing this note four times. Fix the entrance, then we’re moving on.”

Now everyone knows the ticket out of this note and that we won’t be here all day.

adult with sticky note with a large "X" on it covering their mouth

Give the Shortest Explanation That Works

I used to prepare some outstanding rehearsal speeches. Academy Award-worthy material.

A passage didn’t sound right, and instead of simply telling students what needed to change, I would explain phrasing, style, balance, historical context, personal responsibility and possibly the meaning of life. I’d finish this magnificent speech and prepare for the transformed musical experience that was sure to follow. Yes, I’ll be available for autographs and photos later.

Then someone would raise their hand and ask, “So, do we play this note longer or shorter?”

Point taken.

Now I try to give the shortest explanation that produces the most useful result. “Trumpets, that note is too long. Half the length. Everybody at 32.”

Then we play it. If it’s fixed, we move on. If it isn’t, give the next piece of information and try again.

student practicing trumpet in school hallway

Playing and Practicing Aren’t the Same Thing

I’ve written before about not requiring students to practice outside of school. That decision came from the reality that some students simply couldn’t practice at home.

However, there are plenty of kids who can practice who still don’t particularly enjoy it. They do, however, like playing.

“Practice measures 40 through 47” doesn’t mean much to a student. In fact, I can’t recall more than a handful of times when I told a kid to practice, and they effectively practiced.

Instead, give them a specific task and enough music to work with. Tell them, “Play measures 40 through 47 five times. First, get the rhythm right. Then add the dynamics.”

If I need to spend a long time with one section and another group doesn’t need to be involved, I may let students work independently when space and supervision allow it.

My students are comfortable asking, “Can we have a sectional?”

If we’re on the 12th repetition of the third clarinet part and we still have work to do, then yes, go have a sectional.

students holding mallets and playing marimba

NSD: Never Stop Drumming

Percussionists deserve special consideration here.

Obviously, classroom management matters, and percussionists need to stop playing when asked, just like everyone else. But the daily experience of a percussionist often includes substantially less playing than wind players. So, if we spend 20 minutes rehearsing a flute passage, we shouldn’t be shocked when someone starts tapping.

The solution is for percussionists to never stop drumming.

For pieces with little percussion, put students on mallets when appropriate. Double parts or triple them. Sometimes, I’ll give a percussionist an oboe line or another useful wind part to play on a keyboard instrument. They may not perform that part at the concert (often they do). That’s fine. They played it during rehearsal.

For extended wind rehearsing, I keep some practice pads available. My percussionists know that if I’m spending a lot time with the winds, they can move to a soft rubber pad and work through their own material.

concert band strings rehearsal

Move Everything Else Out of Rehearsal

Some of the easiest ways to increase playing time have nothing to do with rehearsal technique. Passing out music takes time, so fill folders outside of class when possible. Give each student a slot or folder location. If you don’t have time to distribute everything yourself (like all of us), assign this task to a couple of students to manage.

Announcements can also become much longer than necessary, so make them once and keep them short. Put the information on the board and send the same information electronically.

One system that helped me was giving section leaders a printed copy of important announcements. They repeated the information to their sections. Attendance improved. Fundraiser forms came back. I also stopped giving the same announcement six times.

Before using rehearsal time for an administrative task, ask: “Could this happen before rehearsal, after rehearsal or without me?” If the answer is yes, move it.

Students will need explanations. Sections will occasionally have to sit and listen. There will be days when rehearsal gets interrupted, and there will be days when one measure takes much longer than you planned. That part of teaching will never change.

But when I have a choice between another speech and another meaningful repetition, I’m trying to choose the repetition more often. Why? They got horns. Let ’em play.

Keep reading